Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed

03 Dec, 2010

by MICHAEL J. CRUMB, AP, via The Huffington Post,

Genetically modified sugar beetsA federal judge in California has ordered the removal from the ground of plants grown to produce seeds for genetically modified sugar beets, citing the potential for environmental harm. The ruling by U.S. District Judge Jeffrey White has again raised questions about the use of genetically modified crops and what will happen if growers aren’t allowed to plant GMO seeds.

About 95 percent of the sugar beet crop has been genetically modified to resist the weed killer Roundup. The crop provides roughly half of the nation’s sugar supply.

In his decision, White cited, “a significant risk of environmental harm.”

White ruled in a lawsuit filed by environmental groups challenging a decision in September by the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Services to issue permits to seed companies to plant sugar beet stecklings. The young plants produce seeds that then are planted to grow sugar beets.

The agency decided to issue the permits despite an August ruling by White that put a hold on future planting of genetically modified sugar beets. The ruling allowed this year’s crop to be harvested and processed, but the current seed crop was not to be planted until the USDA reviewed the effects the crops could have on other food.

In his order Tuesday, White wrote that the environmental groups had shown that the genetically modified sugar beets could contaminate other crops, including through cross-pollination.

“The likely environmental harm . . . is irreparable,” White wrote.

The plants in question would produce seeds for crops to be planted in the spring of 2012. Crops that will be planted next spring won’t be affected by the decision.

Click here to read the rest of this article on HuffingtonPost.com.

About the author

  • http://twitter.com/United_People/status/10743093766656000/ United People (@United_People)

    RT @organicconnect: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed: by MICHAEL J. CRUMB, via The… http://goo.gl/fb/z1oDt

  • http://twitter.com/swannsong/status/10744384752459776/ Holly Golightly (@swannsong)

    RT @organicconnect: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed: by MICHAEL J. CRUMB, via The… http://goo.gl/fb/z1oDt

  • http://twitter.com/coki252000/status/10744911045337088/ Connie (@coki252000)

    RT @organicconnect: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed: by MICHAEL J. CRUMB, via The… http://goo.gl/fb/z1oDt

  • http://twitter.com/dee_deez/status/10746332847280128/ Deborah Dee Dee Zinn (@dee_deez)

    Awww… – Monsanto is having another well-deserved bad day – http://bit.ly/goYv9H #organicconnections via @organicconnect

  • http://twitter.com/Pizzafusionwest/status/10748248222339072/ Pizza Fusion Weston (@Pizzafusionwest)

    RT @dee_deez: Awww… – Monsanto is having another well-deserved bad day – http://bit.ly/goYv9H #organicconnections via @organicconnect

  • http://twitter.com/rawliving/status/10750722962358273/ EarthMother (@rawliving)

    Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Crop to Be Destroyed – http://is.gd/i9nL7 – “The likely environmental harm…is irreparable”

  • http://twitter.com/ArmentaFitness/status/10751979898798080/ Tom Armenta (@ArmentaFitness)

    RT @organicconnect: Monsanto is having another well-deserved bad day – http://bit.ly/goYv9H #organicconnections

  • http://twitter.com/organicconnect/status/10757114934857728/ Organic Connections (@organicconnect)

    Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed: by MICHAEL J. CRUMB, via The Huffington Post,
    A federal… http://bit.ly/dWTGit

  • http://twitter.com/bluebonnetbunny/status/10763129059287040/ Liz (@bluebonnetbunny)

    RT @organicconnect: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed: by MICHAEL J. CRUMB, via The Huffington Post,
    A federal… http://bit.ly/dWTGit

  • http://twitter.com/CyG_GMO/status/10764190046228480/ CyG_GMO (@CyG_GMO)

    Monsanto
    is having another well-deserved bad day. A Judge just ordered the
    destruction of their GMO sugar beet… http://fb.me/PhZQgl5B

  • http://twitter.com/ms_lemon/status/10848604923109376/ Yvonne Michalek (@ms_lemon)

    RT @organicconnect: Monsanto
    is having another well-deserved bad day. A Judge just ordered the
    destruction of their GMO sugar beet… http://fb.me/PhZQgl5B

  • http://twitter.com/SustainablDylan/status/11143488418611200/ Dylan (@SustainablDylan)

    RT @organicconnect: Monsanto just can’t seem to catch a break! Cool! http://bit.ly/goYv9H

  • http://twitter.com/naturaloptions/status/11143520437927936/ Anita (@naturaloptions)

    RT @organicconnect: Monsanto just can’t seem to catch a break! Cool! http://bit.ly/goYv9H

  • http://twitter.com/sportogirl/status/11154427482214400/ sporto (@sportogirl)

    RT @organicconnect: Monsanto just can’t seem to catch a break! Cool! http://bit.ly/goYv9H

  • http://twitter.com/grainsnmore/status/11165297591451648/ Grains&More (@grainsnmore)

    Judge orders #GMO Sugar Beet Seed destroyed http://bit.ly/esJ8wi

  • http://twitter.com/tinapruitt/status/11243463265751040/ Tina Pruitt (@tinapruitt)

    RT @rawliving: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Crop to Be Destroyed – http://is.gd/i9nL7 – “The likely environmental harm…is irreparable”

  • http://twitter.com/shannonwellness/status/11795999597002752/ Shannon Morehouse (@shannonwellness)

    Success (for now at least)! Calif. judge orders #GMO sugar beet crops to be destroyed! http://ow.ly/3kzDb

  • http://twitter.com/GoBeyondHealth/status/11816523853205504/ Winston Kao (@GoBeyondHealth)

    RT @organicconnect: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed | Organic Connections Magazine http://bit.ly/goYv9H #GMO #Monsanto #Sugar-beet #GE

  • http://twitter.com/SurvivingMyWay/status/11817278102310912/ Kate Hopkins (@SurvivingMyWay)

    RT @organicconnect: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed | Organic Connections Magazine http://bit.ly/goYv9H #GMO #Monsanto #Sugar-beet #GE

  • http://twitter.com/luckyopie/status/11863513374916608/ Laura Moore (@luckyopie)

    RT @organicconnect: Monsanto just can’t seem to catch a break! Cool! http://bit.ly/goYv9H

  • http://twitter.com/DasiFriend/status/11897190851022849/ Ann Finster (@DasiFriend) (@DasiFriend)

    RT @organicconnect: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed | Organic Connections Magazine http://bit.ly/goYv9H #GMO #Monsanto #Sugar-beet #GE

  • http://twitter.com/MsMaisyCA/status/11928891002195968/ Maisy (@MsMaisyCA)

    RT @organicconnect: Judge Orders GMO Sugar Beet Seed Plants to Be Destroyed | Organic Connections Magazine http://bit.ly/goYv9H #GMO #Monsanto #Sugar-beet #GE

  • Gil (@GilKeteltas)

    This order was unanimously reversed by the 9th Circuit, so this post is no longer current. http://tinyurl.com/6jb45hm