Twinkies versus Carrots: How Farm Subsidies Buy Obesity and Increase Healthcare Costs

12 Jul, 2012

TwinkiesHave you ever won­dered why a bunch of car­rots costs more than a pack­age of Twinkies? The hid­den truth behind America’s obe­sity epi­demic is that we are buy­ing obe­sity with our tax dol­lars through com­mod­ity crop sub­si­dies in the farm bill. By mak­ing corn prod­ucts arti­fi­cially cheaper, we get a food-like sub­stance, mar­keted as Twinkies, being cheaper to man­u­fac­ture than a car­rot (with­out tax­payer sub­si­dies) is to grow. 

The Twinkie-versus-carrot com­par­i­son can be seen in other foods. Simply start count­ing ingre­di­ents. If it has 40 ingre­di­ents, like the Twinkie, should it really even be called a food? Food has become a mere ingre­di­ent along­side a shelf of tech­ni­cal chem­i­cals cov­er­ing every­thing from taste and mouth feel to color, scent and shelf life. 

We already know that the obe­sity epi­demic is cost­ing hun­dreds of bil­lions of dol­lars in health­care expenses and lost pro­duc­tiv­ity. Farm bill sub­si­dies for com­mod­ity crops sup­port sweet­en­ers like high-fructose corn syrup by pay­ing part of their cost (corn grow­ing) with tax dol­lars. In order to assess the full cost of these crop sub­si­dies, you really need to add the obesity- and diabetes-related health­care costs. 

America is mak­ing indus­trial agri­cul­ture cor­po­ra­tions, along with biotech com­pa­nies and bankers, even more wealthy, all the while increas­ing our health­care costs by a fac­tor of ten or greater! Is this good pub­lic pol­icy or is Washington merely try­ing to keep a bro­ken machine running?

What You Can Do

1. The farm bill for 2012 is still in play in Congress. Let your rep­re­sen­ta­tives know that you expect them to wisely invest your tax dol­lars by cut­ting sub­si­dies for com­mod­ity crops in the farm bill.

2. Vote with your wal­let. When you buy gro­ceries, check the labels to see how many “ingre­di­ents” there are and decide whether what you’re pur­chas­ing is food or not.

Best-selling author, pro­fes­sor and jour­nal­ist Michael Pollan ably con­nects the dots between food pol­icy, com­mod­ity crops and our health in the video below.

GD Star Rating
load­ing...
GD Star Rating
load­ing...
Twinkies ver­sus Carrots: How Farm Subsidies Buy Obesity and Increase Healthcare Costs, 10.0 out of 10 based on 3 ratings

About the author

Related Posts

  • http://www.zcommunications.org/zspace/bradwilson Brad Wilson

    There’s a huge prob­lem here, and yes, it’s caused by the farm bill in large part, (plus trade pol­icy and antitrust pol­icy), but it’s not about sub­si­dies. The PRESENCE of sub­si­dies doesn’t cause it in the farm bill, the ABSENCE of Price Floors causes it. Food stamps are cor­re­lated with a lot of eco­nomic prob­lems, such as with ghet­tos, but they don’t cause those prob­lems. Firetrucks are cor­re­lated with fires, but don’t cause them. It’s the same with sub­si­dies. They par­tially com­pen­sate farm­ers for reduc­tions. Adjusted for infla­tion, com­mod­ity farm­ers were reduced by Congress by about $4 tril­lion since it started in 1953, com­pared to the pre­vi­ous stan­dard (1942-1952). Agribusiness got that ben­e­fit. Farmers were com­pen­sated for the reduc­tions by about 1/8 of the amount (GDP defla­tor, since 1961 when sub­si­dies started) for a net reduc­tion of about $3.5 tril­lion. So, for advo­cacy, elim­i­nate the need for sub­si­dies, oth­er­wise you’re just hurt­ing farm­ers AND fully sup­port­ing cheap HFCS, trans­fats, CAFO feeds, etc. as a mas­sive agribusi­ness ben­e­fit. So sup­port the major “Farm Justice Proposals for the 2012 Farm Bill.” And click my name to learn more.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    GD Star Rating
    loading...
QR Code Business Card